QUOTE (han2503 @ Feb 20 2013, 12:58 PM)

As you can see from the different line-ups I posted above I didn't include Bojan in any. Personally if it were up to me I wouldn't include SES either. However you mentioning Muntari is a huge problem. Having him in that midfield is a huge problem in and of itself no matter where he is played. He is simply such a liability that I cannot even think about him going up against Xavi & Co in that midfield. If Allegri where to actually use his brain he'd realise that he had a perfectly good CM in Constant who is not lazy or slow but is a hard worker who has pace and most importantly, he actually uses his brain.
Constant has been excellent at LB for us. There is simply no way you could justify throwing him into CM and using a weaker option at the back.
There really is so much hate from you and X Off about Muntari. I'm not sure it's entirely fair!
QUOTE
As for the formation, I'd prefer a 3-man backline. Like you said, we need to keep it tight, and to keep it tight you have to pile bodies in there so that we don't get exposed in certain areas when players from midfield get pulled onto the wings to cover
As I've said before, 3 man at the back requires massive understanding between all 3, and 2 WB's who don't stop running all day. It's a formation you need to practise a lot before you can be assured it will work. It's not really the right match to try this in. Although we are agreed that if it works, it is exactly what we need. But we just don't have the experience with the formation to use it.
QUOTE
He liked playing him everywhere but in his position. When it was obvious that he couldn't hack it on the RW he discarded him for Niang/Prince neither of which were actually better there but that's irrelevant in this case. Personally I always felt Urby was a very good utility player, he's decent in midfield, gives us options to switch the system, and according to Allegri can play anywhere bar the GK position. It's the way he was used that always irked me personally
You've described him as a utility player but then said 'his position'. What IS his position? As for midfield, he was a cheap and cheerful version of Seedorf but without that marquee class.
Seedorf is, of course, one of the greatest players the game has ever seen. And one of the most decorated.